Sunday, April 30, 2006

II-A

Babylonian Talmud

Berachot 44b

4 comments:

Yeedle said...

You built this list partially on the premise that: scientific matter + dispute between sages = scientific matter not Torah. I thing this is wrong and misleading. See Ritva Chagiga 14b.

DES said...

I can't find your reference, but I don't agree with (or don't understand) your description of my premise.

My premise is simply that if Talmudic rabbis disputed a scientific point -- i.e., a description of some aspect of the world or how it operates -- one side (or more) was presumably incorrect in its description -- i.e., in its scientific belief. This is true regardless of why they were debating or what arguments they summoned as evidence.

First Last said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
First Last said...

I think you should add the gemara in sanhedrin 91b - the stories with Rebbe and Antoninus