You built this list partially on the premise that: scientific matter + dispute between sages = scientific matter not Torah. I thing this is wrong and misleading. See Ritva Chagiga 14b.
I can't find your reference, but I don't agree with (or don't understand) your description of my premise.My premise is simply that if Talmudic rabbis disputed a scientific point -- i.e., a description of some aspect of the world or how it operates -- one side (or more) was presumably incorrect in its description -- i.e., in its scientific belief. This is true regardless of why they were debating or what arguments they summoned as evidence.
I think you should add the gemara in sanhedrin 91b - the stories with Rebbe and Antoninus
Post a Comment